151 posts in less than 12 hours thanks to a mention by the mighty Atrios! I don't mind telling you I'm flabbergasted. I was mildly disappointed not to get any mail regarding my post, but this is small beer, as they say. (I did get an unsolicited e-mail promising to sell me the latest in spam-filtering software, which is kind of amusing.)

Anyway, upon reflection, maybe Atrios/Eschaton is right-- perhaps it's more apt to say that Suellentrop was highly likely to have been influenced by Ratliff's review rather than to suggest that he lifted it outright.